When People Laugh At Your Brand

[Cache #220]

By Andris Pone – President, Coin Branding

This seems a safe guess:  that most of us would rather not toil for years on defining a consistent brand in the marketplace, only to have it publicly mocked.

But sometimes – very rarely – the mockery is not mockery just for the sake of mockery.  It is in fact the highest form of respect that any individual or organizational brand can ever be paid.

We are not talking about, say, This Hour Has 22 Minutes making fun of Air Canada throwing their passengers’ luggage.  Because Air Canada has indeed been caught on video throwing their passengers’ luggage – and throwing luggage is a bad thing – that would be mockery for mockery, intended as an insult.  Rather, we are talking about someone making fun of your finest accomplishments, as The Onion, a satirical news outlet, has just done to Southwest Airlines.

Southwest is the airline that has received the fewest customer complaints of any US carrier since 1987.  In 2014, Fortune magazine named them one of America’s Most Admired Companies for the 20th consecutive year.  Also in 2014, Southwest enjoyed their 42nd straight year of profitability.  All the while, they have been recognized by top publications including Forbes and Glassdoor as one of America’s best companies to work for.

How, exactly, do you make fun of a brand with that kind of, well, brand?  You run a story entitled “Southwest Airlines Rolls Out New ‘Loyalty Goes Both Ways’ Campaign.”  As the video report explains, “The friendly airline says that while they’re proud to have the most loyal customers in the business, it’s time to find out what their customers are willing to do for them.”

As a Southwest mechanic puts it, “Over the years, we’ve asked for so little.”  A poised flight attendant continues:  “Now I expect everyone who’s flown Southwest in the past five years to come to my house, and help me move this weekend.”

The most pressing appeal comes in a radio ad from the organization’s top dog.  “Hi.  This is Southwest CEO Gary Kelly.  If my wife calls asking about me, I need you to lie and say I was with you.  Remember all those low fares I gave you.”

It’s been said that making the cover of Time or Rolling Stone is the ultimate sign that you’re a player – that your brand matters.  But maybe the ultimate recognition occurs when a publication like The Onion, which treats its targets entirely viciously with regularity – can only make fun of your strengths.

It’s not the moment to stop working, but it’s the moment you’ve truly arrived.

– See the Onion’s story here (warning: some foul language) – 

I was honoured to guest lecture at my alma mater, the Schulich School of Business, this week.  Thank you to the accomplished and inquisitive students in the fourth-year social media class of Aleem Visram.  My topic:  What A Brand Really Is, and How to Express Yours On LinkedIn.

Share this: